4 Best Places to Eat a Hand-Rolled Bagel in the City

Hand-Rolled Bagel

If you’re looking for a delicious hand-rolled bagel, then you have come to the right place. From scratch-made bagels to homemade spreads and toppings, this neighborhood joint offers something for everyone. Read on to learn more about these tasty delights. Listed below are some of the best places in the city to enjoy a hand-rolled bagel. Let’s start with Sammy’s: This small, family-owned business offers fresh-baked bagels that are always warm and fresh.

Utopia Bagels

New York Bagels are a busting staple of any NYC neighborhood. In an otherwise simple, compact space, these hand-rolled bagels are made to order. And with a hefty price tag, you can be sure that you’ll leave feeling satisfied. And while there’s nothing quite like a warm, freshly-baked bagel, these hand-rolled favorites are sure to please any taste bud.

The owners of Utopia Bagels have been working in the bagel business for decades. They devoted their lives to the business and hoped to give their community the best possible experience. With their attention to detail, Utopia has become an institution, with long lines during their busiest hours. As a community resource, they donate surplus food to local soup kitchens and churches. This way, they’re giving back to the community as well as helping the planet.

Spellman has been running Utopia Bagels for about a year after replacing a long-time employee. When customers call the shop, she answers with a cheery, book-perfect voice. “Bagels, can I help you?”

After the bagel shop gained some traction on social media and in publications, Jesse decided to expand his business. Now he ships to Hawaii and Alaska, and has plans to fulfill about 150 orders daily. He anticipates over 400 during the holiday season. As a result of the overwhelming success, the shop also has a mobile food truck and caters to private events. There are several locations in the NYC area where you can find Utopia Bagels.

In addition to being a staple in a neighborhood, Utopia Bagels has earned a spot in the hearts and minds of visitors and locals alike. The delicious, affordable grub at Utopia Bagels is the perfect breakfast or lunch treat. Tourists and locals alike are lining up for a hand-rolled bagel. A vote for the best bagel in the city will make you feel a part of the Utopia family.


Scratch-made bagels are the hallmark of this compact neighborhood joint. Choose from a variety of toppings and spreads for an authentic New York experience. A small but well-stocked condiment bar helps you customize your bagel experience. And, while it may be small, Sammy’s is a must-stop for those in the know. In the neighborhood since 1957, Sammy’s has earned a reputation for consistently making fresh bagels.

A native New Yorker, Pullano’s experience in making bagels was honed when he was a teenager, running deliveries for Manhattan’s famous Jumbo Bagels. After graduating from college, he opened his first bagels shop in 1992 and sold it in 2000. He later opened an Italian restaurant in Athens, where he and his wife raised two children. When they moved to Columbus in 2009, they realized there was room for even more delicious bagels.

At the Sammy’s Bagels facility, you’ll find stacks of wooden trays dusted with cornmeal. These wooden trays hold the dough and allow it to proof overnight before hitting the oven. They are then placed on burlap-covered wooden planks and baked for about 15 minutes. The bagels are baked until golden brown. Dennis Samoilis first started making bagels when he was 17, learning from “old-timers” in bagel shops in the early 1970s. Fourteen years later, he opened his first bagels shop.

Today, Sammy’s Bagels can be found in the heart of Midtown Manhattan and midtown Nashville. For lunch, a Jimmy Sammy, a popular sandwich, is available on Wednesdays only. It comes with a freshly rolled bagel, lightly breaded chicken cutlet, family recipe special sun-dried tomato aioli, and light kale salad. Only available during lunchtime, the Jimmy Sammy is a unique creation.

Alfa Bagels

When it comes to eating a fresh, hand-rolled bagel, few places can compare to Alfa Bagels. Located on Route 10 in Randolph, New Jersey, Alfa Bagels boasts that it makes the largest bagels in the state! Along with its famous bagels, the deli menu includes breakfast sandwiches, omelets, desserts, and lunch sandwiches. For those looking for a quick and inexpensive lunch option, Alfa Bagels is the place to go.

Whether you want to enjoy a toasted bagel or a fresh-baked version, there is a bagel to suit your taste. The bagels are made fresh each morning and come in a variety of flavors. You can choose from flat, mini, and stuffed. In addition, you can purchase a bagel that has been filled with a delicious cream cheese! You can even order your favorite bagel online.

For something a little less traditional, try the sun-dried tomato bagel. The sun-dried tomato bagel is a tasty, unique, and slightly sweet combination. Another popular flavor is the lemon & onion bagel, which is the perfect combination of chewy and crispy. This bagel shop also offers salads and burgers to complete your meal. You can’t go wrong with either!

Among the best bagels in New York City is the Golden Arches bagel. It has the famous “hungry man’s breakfast” that includes a bagel, egg sandwich, hashbrowns, and coffee. The location is small enough to eat in, but the line tends to be long, especially on weekends. However, once you’ve tried one of the giant bagels, you’ll want to go back for another round.


This small neighborhood bagel joint offers scratch-made bagels and other scratch-made items. Whether you want to top them with cheese, lox, or just plain butter, Salemme’s hand-rolled bagels are delicious. The resulting bagel sandwich will make you forget you’re even in the city. You’ll want to come back again for the delicious breakfast and lunch options, which include a variety of spreads and toppings.

The menu at Salemme’s is diverse, with 13 varieties available. Other options include salami, cream cheese, egg and omelet platters, and muffins. A full deli is also available, complete with salami, cheese, and meat. The deli section includes a deli section, which is a welcome addition to any breakfast experience. There’s no need to leave your house for breakfast.

After serving time in prison on racketeering charges, Salemme and other mobsters were arrested in 1996. He pleaded guilty and was sentenced to eleven years in prison. However, his connection with the Patriarca family made him a prime suspect. His close relationship with Whitey Bulger and his lieutenant Steve Flemmi made him a trusted associate of Bulger. After Salemme was released, he attempted to control the Patriarca family. However, the decision was met with resistance from Joseph Russo and Angelo Mercurio, who had luring him to a meeting with Salemme and the Patriarcas. As a result, the two men were shot by the FBI, and Salemme was sentenced to 11 years in prison.

Sammy’s with cream cheese and lox

Sammy’s bagels are renowned for their cream cheese and cream. The New York-style bagels are also top-notch. You can find classics like egg sammies or creative treats like spinach pimento cheddar and breadstick-shaped bagels. While there is no physical location, you can order online and have them delivered to your door the next morning. You can also bring your own cream cheese and lox to enjoy on a toasted bagel.